Well, looks like discussing the games whilst judging the IF Competition is against the rules. I’m not exactly sure what this is supposed to accomplish, particularly as its only in public forums discussing is disallowed.. there’s nothing stopping judges getting together and discussing in private.
In anycase, i’ve removed the reviews I previously posted. I might post them back sometime after the competition is over. Till then, go over to http://www.ifcomp.org and download the games if you wish to see for yourself.